Current Issue

2023: Volume 4, Issue 3

Edible Medicinal Plants of Mediterranean Region and Consumer Behavior

Saadet Tuğrul Ay¹,*, Asaf Özalp¹, Ladin Ay2

1Antalya Metropolitan Municipality, Department of Agricultural Services, Yüksekalan Mahallesi Adnan Menderes Bulvarı No. 20, Muratpaşa, Antalya 07310, Türkiye

2Ondokuz Mayıs University Faculty of Medicine, Kurupelit Campus, 55139 Atakum / SAMSUN, Türkiye

*Corresponding Author: Saadet Tuğrul Ay, Antalya Metropolitan Municipality, Department of Agricultural Services, Türkiye; Email: [email protected]

Received Date: October 18, 2023

Publication Date:  November 1, 2023

Citation: Tuğrul Ay S, et al. (2023). Edible Medicinal Plants of Mediterranean Region and Consumer Behavior. Traditional Medicine. 4(3):18.

Copyright Tuğrul Ay S, et al. © (2023). 

ABSTRACT

Bioavailability has an important place in human nutrition by creating healthy nutrition options, food assurance, and positive effects on human health. Plants that grow by themselves in nature have great importance on our nutritional culture. Also because the availability of edible plants in the wild is not related to the economic status of the person, they are very important for the nutrition of our society.Turkey, with its rich flora, is endowed with the greatest number of medicinal and aromatic plants in Europe, which are mostly found growing in the wild. Due to industrialization and urbanization, and the migration of Turkish people to cities from rural areas, traditional knowledge on these wild plants has started to vanish. This knowledge, which derives from the historical use of natural resources, is still being used by many food and drug industries. However, risks arising from the improper use of species that have not been medically studied and approved should not be overlooked. For this reason, multidisciplinary studies must be undertaken to document the medicinal benefits of these traditional plants.

The Biodiversity for Nutrition and Food (BFN) Project, carried out from 2012-2019, documented important information on the use of regional plants and wild species in the Mediterranean, Black Sea and Aegean regions of Turkey. In the Mediterranean Region, which this paper will focus on, of the 20 documented species, 17 were reported as being used both as medicinal and food plants while the remaining 2 species were only used for medicinal purposes. Consumers of these species use the plants for common health problems such as diabetes, gastrointestinal diseases, flu, kidney stones, cough, oral and dental diseases, and cardiovascular diseases. The scope of this study includes the evaluation of the traditional use and medicinal application of wild edible plants (WEP) of the Mediterranean region compared to the same plant species from different studies that have been conducted. The scope of this study also includes the present medicinal benefits of edible medicinal plants and determining factors that affect the consumption and consumption habits of these plants.

According to results that have been obtained, the most commonly known plants out of the 20 plants that have been detected as edible medicinal species are Syrian Juniper (40%) and Elm Leaved Sumach (35%). Plants with the most commonly known medicinal benefits are also found to be Syrian Juniper and Elm Leaved Sumach and although they are not overall commonly known, when their benefits were known they were observed to be more likely to be consumed by the consumers. 6 factors are affecting the consumption of edible medicinal plants by consumers according to the factor analysis that has been done in the research. These are 1. Information and Availability, 2. Marketing, 3. Healthy Eating, 4. Taste and Benefit, 5. Brand and Awareness, 6. Cultivation Technique.

Keywords: Traditional knowledge, wild edibles plants, medicinal values, consumption habbits, factor analysis

INTRODUCTION

According to the “Flora of Turkey and The East Aegean Islands”, Turkey’s is home to an astounding 1251 genera from 174 plant families, more than 12,000 species and taxon subspecies (subgenre and variety) (Davis 1985-1988, Güner et al. 2000) [1,2]. 234 of these taxa are of foreign origin and cultivars. The remaining species are endemic to Turkey (Ekim et al. 1989, Erik and Tarıkahya 2004) [3,4]. Considering the whole European continent has only about 12,000 plant taxa in total, it is greatly evident that Turkey is very rich in vegetation flora (Ekim et al. 2000) [5].

Although the exact number of medicinal plants in Turkey is not known, it has been estimated to be about 500. Also, it it should be highlighted that about 200 medicinal and aromatic plants have exportation potential (Baytop 1999; Ekim et al. 2000, Aydın 2004) [5-7], and most of these plant species are found in the Mediterranean region. It is thus crucial to understand the value of these plants, particularly in the Mediterranean region. This region has the highest endemism in Turkey.

The Mediterranean region has 20 important areas that are rich in plant biodiversity. The most important provinces are Konya housing 1396 taxa and 428 endemic species, İçel with 1724 taxa and 399 endemics, Karaman with 331 taxa and 150 endemics, and Antalya with 2126 taxa and 572 endemics (Anonymous 2023) [8].

Our study that has been conducted in the Mediterranean region which is very rich in plant species diversity, we aimed to demonstrate the medicinal benefits of edible medicinal plants that have been detected in the scope of the study with research that has been done and determining factors that affecting consumption and consumption habits of these plants.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In this study, a monographic research technique was used. Information was gathered by interviewing 484 wild plant gatherers and consumers from four provinces, 17 districts, and 31 villages including in the provinces of Antalya, Konya, İçel and Karaman (Table 1) (Figure 2). Documented wild species and regional plants were researched in detail, from production to consumption. Ethnobotanical information on the sustainable use of this diversity was also obtained via BFN. (Karabak 2017) [9].

Due to the increasing importance of these compounds on human health, polyphenols analysis and antioxidant activity evaluation were also carried out using 2,2- diphenyl-1-picrylhydrazyl radical scavenging effect (DPPH) and Trolox equivalent antioxidant capacity/ABTS radical cation decolorization assay method (TEAC) (Ayas et al. 2017) [10].

Table 1: Study area in the provinces of Antalya, Konya, Icel and Karaman and target species of the Mediterranean Region.

Province

ANTALYA

KONYA

İÇEL

KARAMAN

District

Gündoğmuş

Taşkent

Aslanköy (Erdemli)

Ermenek

Akseki

Beyşehir

Mut

Ayrancı

Korkuteli

Derebucak

Gülnar

 

Elmalı

Ereğli

Tarsus

 

Gazipaşa

Halkapınar

Çamlıyayla

 

Specıes

1. Juniperus drupacea Labill. (Andız, Pekmez ardıcı)

6. Eremurus spectabilis M. Bieb. (Çiriş)

14. Gundelia tournefortii L. (Kenger)

15. Ferula elaeochytris Korovin (Çakşır)

2. Pyrus serikensis Güner & H. Duman (Serik Armudu)

7. Nasturtium officinale R. Br., Aiton (Su teresi)

16. Scorzonera cana (C.A. Mey.) Griseb (Dedem sakalı)

3. Dioscorea communis (L.) Caddick & Wilkin (Kuşkonmaz)

8. Lupinus albus L. (Termiye, Tirmis)

17. Gypsophila arrostii subsp. nebulosa (Boiss. & Heldr.) Greuter & Burdet (Çöven)

4. Chondrilla juncea L. (Gara gavruk)

9. Acorus calamus L. (Eğir)

18. Rhus coriaria L. (Sumak)

5. Colocasia esculenta (L.) Schott (Gölevez)

10. Capparis spinosa L. (Kebere, Kapari)

19. Tragopogon porrifolius subsp. longirostris (Sch.Bip.) Greuter (Yemlik)

 

11. Eriolobus trilobatus (Labill. ex Poir.) At Elması

20. Cichorium intybus L. (Güneyik, Karahindiba)

 

12. Ferulago trachycarpa Boiss. (Çakşır, çaşır)

 
 

13. Berberis crataegina DC. (Karamuk)

 
 

 

Figure: The Four Provinve in The Mediterranean Region in the provinces of Antalya, Konya, Icel and Karaman.

The second stage of the study is to reveal consumer preferences for the plants identified within the scope of the project and the factors affecting these preferences. At this stage, the primary data of this study formed from information obtained from 200 surveys conducted by face-to-face interviews with families selected by sampling method in the city center of Antalya province. During the survey phase of the study, a pilot survey was prepared in order to determine the sufficient sample size for the study and to correct the shortcomings of the survey to be applied. These prepared surveys were applied to 10 randomly selected people. Based on the results obtained from the pilot survey, the survey form then was reviewed, adjustments were made and the main survey was finalized. The data obtained from the survey application was evaluated in the SPSS package program. During the data processing phase, averages, proportional values, and cross-relationships between important variables were explained.

In the study, factor analysis, which is among the multivariate analysis techniques, was used to determine the factors affecting the consumption preferences of edible medicinal plants in order to reduce the number of variables expressed as sub-variables and make them more easily understandable. Factor analysis aims to find factors among observed variables. If there are too many variables, this analysis is applied to reduce the number of variables and make them easier to interpret (Hair et al., 1992) [11].

The factor analysis was applied using the SPSS package program. Factor analysis can be summarized in three stages.

1. A correlation matrix is created for all variables.

2. Factors are extracted from the correlation matrix based on the correlation coefficients of the variables.

3. Factors are subjected to rotation to maximize the relationship between some of the factors and variables.

In our study, reliability measurements were made for the variables used in factor analysis. Reliability refers to the consistency of a measurement. It is a measurement that should be taken into consideration, especially in studies where behavioral evaluations are made. It is not desirable for the reliability value in behavioral studies to fall below 80%. Reliability can be measured in different ways. These measurements can be listed as follows (Oppenhaim,1992) [12];

•              Test-Retest reliability

•              internal consistency

•              Split-half method

•              Parallel form method

Cronbach's alpha coefficient, which is among the internal consistency methods, is the most commonly used reliability coefficient. This coefficient enables the series of variables to be measured in one dimension. Cronbachalpha should be low when the data has a multidimensional structure. Cronbach alpha is not a statistical test but a reliability or consistency coefficient.

Cronbachalpha can be written as a function of the number of variables to be tested and the correlation between variables.

In the formula;

N: Number of variables

r ̅: Shows the average of correlation between variables.

Cronbach alpha coefficient can be interpreted as a correlation coefficient. This coefficient takes values between 0 and 1. Negative values indicate that there is no positive relationship between the factors. In such a case, the reliability model is invalid. If the coefficient found is approaching 1, it means that the model is quite reliable. On the other hand, as its value approaches 0, reliability decreases.

The general purpose of factor analysis is to express the information present in a large number of main variables in a smaller number of dimensions (in factor variables) and to reveal the factor structure represented by the variables. As a result of factor analysis in the study, the factor structure of consumption preferences of edible medicinal plants was revealed.

Study Findings

In the study, 20 plant species were found to be used both in traditional medicine and for food. Ethnobotanical data about these species were compiled and their medicinal value evaluated in the light of the obtained information.

Calamus - Eğir otu (Acorus calamus L.)

In Turkish traditional medicine, it is used as a gas pain reliever, appetite stimulator and anti-coagulant. It is also used to cure nausea, digestive disorders and in tooth extraction procedures. The plant’s rhizomes have many ethnomedical and ethnobotanical uses. It is not consumed for food. In Indian and Chinese medicine, it is known as rattan and is used to aid memory, improve learning performance, prevent lipid peroxidation and anti-aging effects as well as an appetite stimulator and digestion-supporter. Also, it has healing properties for fever and stomach cramps. Its rhizomes can be used unprocessed, chewed for tooth pain and by processing it to powder and drinking it for throat ache (Palani et al. 2009) [13]. Essential oil extracted from the leaves, rhizomes, and the plant itself has antispasmodic and antiflatulent effects. Its rhizomes are used for epilepsy, mental disorders, chronic diarrhea, dysentery, intermittent fever, bronchitis, cold, throat ache and tumortreatment (Devi et al. 2011) [14]. It also has antifungal, antibacterial, and insecticidal properties (Rupali et al.  2011) [15]. This plant is utilized because of its sedative, anti-diarrheal, anti-dyslipidemic, neuroprotective, antioxidant, anticholinesterase, spasmolytic and vasculomodulator activities (Mehrotra et al. 2003) [16]. It has been detected that the plant’s rhizomes and leaves have mitogenic and anticarcinogenic effects on human lymphocytes (Palani et al. 2009) [13]. As a result of our questionnaire and project studies, the most common regional use of Calamus in Turkey is for indigestion.

Elm Leaved Sumach-Sumak (Rhus coriaria L.)

It is used both as a spice that adds flavor to food and in traditional medicine. Dried sumach fruits are ground, separated from the seeds and used as a popular spice in the Middle East. With its sour taste and red color, it adds flavor in cooking and creates an impressive colour in dishes. Sumach is used in dishes such as stuffed grape leaves/peppers, sauces, olives olive pastes etc. The product that is obtained from the decoction of Sumach stem and leaves is used for gastrointestinal infections while the product the decoction of ripe fruits is used for expelling kidney stones. Chewing of sumach fruits, like gum, is also known to be used for treating mouth wounds and stomach cramps (Güner 2012, Tuzlacı 2006, Tuzlacı 2011) [2,17,18]. Sumach is used in the treatment of dysentery, conjunctivitis, liver diseases and anorexia as well as in burn and dermatitis-like skin disorders treatment (Ali Shtayeh et al. 2013) [19]. The results of a study showed that high consumption of sumach might have a protective effect against atherosclerosis, oxidative stress, and liver enzymes, due to high-fat food stress (Setorki et al. 2012) [20]. In a study undertaken in Azerbaijan it was shown that the fruits have a laxative effect and are also used for hypertension and diabetes (Hasanova 2000) [21].

Ferula-Çağ (Ferula elaeochytris Korovin)

Ferula root and above-ground parts are known to be used for their aphrodisiac effect and in the treatment of prostatic disease, while the root is used for the treatment of infertility and diabetes (Akan 2015, Kocabaş and Gedik 2016) [22,23]. In regional farmers’ markets, Plant root extracts are reported to have positive effects in slowing down the development of age-related erectile dysfunction (a serious public health problem with a high prevalence and adverse effects on the quality of life in elderly men) (Eser et al. 2020) [24]. Honey made from Ferula elaeochytris flowers is used to increase sexual desire. Ferula is also used as a pain reliever, as a sedative, and to aid digestion as well as for the treatment of gynecological diseases, digestive disorders and respiratory disorders in traditional medicine (Akbulut 2015) [25]. It has been found that excessive ingestion of the plant causes allergy in cattle (Sargın and Büyükgebiz 2019) [26]. Its root can be boiled and used as a tea for medicinal purposes.

Kuzukemirdi (Ferulago trachycarpa Boiss.)

Traditionally used for its medicinal properties as well as food in salads and as a spice (Akalın and Alpınar 1994) [27]. It is used as a nervous system sedative, carminative, aphrodisiac, dewormer, antidepressant and for the treatment of gastrointestinal diseases and hemorrhoids (Özhatay and Akalın 1998) [28]. As a food item, that can be pickled to be eaten later or used as a preservative and aromatizer for milk products like cheese (Şatır 2006) [29].

Common chicory - Hindiba (Cichorium intybus L.)

It can be used both as a medicinal plant and as food. The whole plant contains important medical compounds such as inulin, esculin, and volatile compounds (monoterpenes and sesquiterpenes), coumarins, flavonoids and vitamins. Also, processed common chicory powder is used commercially to produce several raw food materials such as chicory powder, agglomerated powder, flour, roasted cubes, chocolate flavoring and liquid extract. It has been detected in studies that the root extract of this plant has anticarcinogenic, antitumor and immunomodulator properties (Angelina et al. 1999, Hazra 2002) [30,31]. Common Chicory is used as an additive in coffee to relieve gastritis (Bremness 1998) [32]. Also, sesquiterpene lactones such as lactusin and lactucopicrin present in the plant are used for their antibacterial, antimalarial (Bischoff et al. 2004) [33] and antifungal activities (Monde et al. 1990; Nishmura et al. 1999) [34,35]. Dried common chicory root is used for its diuretic properties as well as for the treatment of stomach, liver, and spleen enlargement; gout, fever, rheumatic complaints, vomiting and diarrhea in tonic form (Kokate 2006, Chopra 2002) [36,37]. While its leaves are used in salads, its dried and ground roots are used as a coffee alternative.

Rush skeletonweed - Karakavuk (Chondrilla juncea L.)

It is used in traditional medicine and cooking. Gum can be produced from the sap that exudes from cutting the bottom part of its trunk. This gum is chewed to prevent tooth decay as well as for treating stomachaches. When condensed, the sap can be used as hair removal wax (Senkardes 2014) [38]. Extracts of rush skeletonweed are used for stomach aches while its leaves are used for healing wounds (Çakıloğlu and Türkoğlu 2009) [39,]. The bottom leaves of the plant are used in traditional dishes (Uzun 2015) [40]. Raw leaves of the plant can be added to salads (Deniz vd. 2010) [41].

Salsify - Teke Sakalı (Scorzonera cana (C.A.Mey.) Griseb)

It is used both as a medicinal plant and as food. The genus is used in traditional medicine in Turkey, Europe, China and Mongolia for different purposes (Tsevegsuren et al. 2007, Baytop 1999, Zidorn et al. 2000) [42-44]. In Turkish folk medicine salsify species are used to treat arteriosclerosis, kidney diseases, hypertension, diabetes mellitus, rheumatism and for pain relief as well as wound healing (Baytop 1999, Sezik 1997) [43,45]. Studies on the Scorzonera genus reveal the antinociceptive, anti-inflammatory and wound healing properties of some species that have been evaluated and promising results have been obtained for further studies (Bahadır 2009, Siintar et al. 2012) [46,47]. Many species are edible. Both their roots and green buds are edible (Baytop 1999, Turan et al. 2003) [43,48].

Purple Salsify - Helevan (Tragopogon porrifolius subsp. longirostris (Sch.Bip.) Greuter)

In Turkey this genus is represented by 21 members (Davis 1975, Güner et al. 2000) [1,2]. The genera is used in traditional medicine. T. porrifolius is used, in European folk medicine, for its antibilious, diuretic, and laxative effects and in Lebanese folk medicine for treating cancer (Formisano et al. 2010; Tenkerian 2011) [49,50]. In Turkish folk medicine, the aerial parts of T. coloratus, T. dubius, T. pratensis ssp. orientalis, T. pterocarpus and T. reticulatus are used in the treatment of stomachache. The use of the latex and leaves of T. buphtalmoides var. buphtalmoides and the use of the stem and leaves of T. longirostris to cure intestinal disorders as well as antihelminthic activities of some Tragopogon species have been recorded (Uğur et al. 2009, Altundağ and Öztürk 2011) [51,52]. The anticancer, antioxidant and hepatoprotective activities of T. porrifolius have also been recently reported (Tenkerian 2011) [50]. The plant has bioactive compounds that prevent cancer or other free radical-associated illnesses. The nutritional value of this plant is derived from monounsaturated and essential fatty acids, polyphenols, vitamins, and fructo-oligosaccharides, having probiotic effects on the intestinal microflora (Formisano 2010, Konopiński 2009) [49]. Among them, Tragopogon porrifolius L., known as white salsify, is used as a vegetable in Europe as well as in Turkey (Formisano et al. 2010, Baytop 1999) [43,49]. It cultivated for its ornamental flowers and edible root. The root and the young shoots of T. porrifolius can be eaten (after being boiled) and are used as vegetables (Zidorn 2010; Lyons 1956) [44,51]. The freshly grown leaves can be eaten cooked or raw (Heistinger 2013, Niering and Olmstead 1985) [52,53]. The aerial parts of T. porrifolius and some other Tragopogon species are eaten freshly or after cooked (Turan et al. 2003, Uğur et al. 2009) [51,54].

Gundelia -Kenger (Gundelia tournefortii L.)

It is used both as a medicinal plant and as food. Traditionally, G. tournefortii (L.) is used for the treatment of liver diseases, diabetes, chest pain, heart stroke, gastric pain, vitiligo, diarrhea, and bronchitis. It is also reported to have hypoglycaemic, laxative, sedative, anti-inflammatory, anti-parasitic, antiseptic and emetic effects. The leaves, stems, roots, and immature flower buds are edible when they first sprout in early spring. The plant is used fresh or cooked and prepared like artichokes.

Berberis- Karamuk (Berberis crataegina DC.)

The plant is used in the medical, food and textile industries. Traditionally it is used for the treatment of infertility, hemorrhoids, rheumatic arthritis, headache, pulmonary-vascular diseases and gynecological diseases (Tuzlacı, E. 2016) [55]. Berberine, found in the woody parts of the Berberis plant provides a yellow dye, which is traditionally used for dyeing wool and yarn. Berberis stems, shells, fruits, and leaves have phenolic compounds, alkaloids and flavonoids and are used in Anatolia for treating fever, flu, rheumatical disorders, eye diseases, gastrointestinal problems and respiratory tract diseases as well as for lowering blood sugar. B. crataegina contains tannins, organic acids (malic, tartic, citric acids), vitamin C and high levels of anthocyanins. The berberis fruit water excretion was researched for α-amylase and α-glucosidase. Despite inhibiting both enzymes, it has a greater inhibitory effect on α-glucosidase (Gedikli 2006) [56]. Extracts from stems and shells of various Berberis species are used in traditional medicine for the treatment of various inflammatory disorders such as rheumatic arthritis and fever (Yeşilada and Küpeli 2002) [57]. Berberis crataegina (kızamık) and Rumex scutatus (ekşimük) leaves can be eaten raw (Cansaran et al. 2007) [58]. The plant’a vitamin C-rich fruit can be consumed as a tea, garnish, or used to make compotes, syrups, jams, and jellies (Borelli et al. 2022) [59].

Watercress - Su teresi (Nasturtium officinale R.Br., Aiton)

It can be used both as a medicinal plant and as food. Watercress is rich in vitamins. It is known for being health strengthening, correcting vitamin deficiency, diuretic, appetite-stimulating, sedative and a digestive aid. It has been recorded to be used for eczema and skin wounds by applying dried watercress leaves mixed with honey directly to the skin (Baytop 1999) [43]. Also, it is used for the treatment of urinary tract infections and headaches. Traditionally it is used as a digestive aid and in treating liver diseases (Everest and Öztürk, 2005) [60]. Watercress leaves can be used raw in salads (Özer et al. 1999) [61].

Caper Bush-Kapari (Capparis spinosa L.)

It can be used as food and medecine. The plant contains many phytochemicals and bioactive compounds and is traditionally used for treating a host of diseases (Argentieri et al. 2012) [62]. The caper’s flower seeds are antioxidant and are thought to suppress cancerous cells, while inhibiting the harmful effects of carcinogens in the body. Studies conducted in the International Cancer Research Institute, have included caper extracts in antitumoral preparations (Anonymous 1997) [8]. Several studies have shown capers to have immunomodulator, hepatoprotective, analgesic, antidiabetic, anti-inflammatory, antiallergenic, antidepressant, antioxidant, antitumoral, diuretic, antidiarrheal, hypoglycemic, mucolytic, antibacterial, antiviral, anthelmintic, antifungal, antiallergenic, antihypertensive, antiatherosclerotic and antihyperlipidemic effects (Singh et al. 2011, Tlili et al. 2010, Argentieri et al. 2012, Huseini et al. 2013) [62-65]. The plant’s fruits/seeds are used pickled or canned. Capers are used in salads, on dough bases as well as a garnish for meat and fish dishes.

Arrost's baby's-breath - Çöven  (Gypsophila arrostii subsp. nebulosa)

It is used as a medicinal plant and food. Containin saponin, it is a good foamer. It is used as a cleaner and emulsifier as well as for extracting saponin (Tanker et al. 1998) [66]. Arrost's baby's-breath has diuretic, diaphoretic, antipyretic, relaxant, emetic, expectorant and cleansing properties and is also used in skin diseases. (Öztürk et al. 2000) [67]. Its main component, saponin, is extracted by boiling the rhizomes and used as an additive in the production of desserts called "Tahini Halva", "Koz Halva" and "Pasha Turkish Delight". (Velioğlu 2001) [68].

Syrian Juniper - Andız (Juniperus drupacea)

It has medicinal and food uses. In traditional Turkish medicine, Syrian Juniper fruits are used as a diuretic, antiseptic and in the treatment of gastrointestinal problems (Baytop 1999) [43]. The anti-inflammatory potential of Syrian Juniper has been detected empirically and its use has spread to traditional medicine in different European countries (Mascolo et al. 1987; Tunon et al. 1995) [48,69]. Fruits of the plant are traditionally used to cure migraines, rheumatoid arthritis and gout. Native Americans used the fruit to treat diabetes (Tilford, 1997, McCabe et al. 2005) [70,71]. The whole plant is used as an anti-inflammatory, diuretic, emmenagogue, sudorific, carminative and in the treatment of digestive disorders (Pepeljnjak et al. 2005, Gumral et al. 2013) [72,73]. In several studies, the essential oil of the Syrian Jumper fruit has been shown to have inhibitory effects on multi-bacterial growth (Filipowicz et al. 2003, Pepeljnjak et al. 2005) [72,74]. Further, due to the antiprogesterone activity of Syrian Jumper extract, the plant has anti-fertility effects (Pathak et al. 1990) [75]. Its fruits are used as the main ingredient of molasses.

Black Bryony - Dolambaç (Dioscorea communis (L.) Caddick & Wilkin)

It has uses in both the medical and food sector. Black Bryony roots are used in muscle ache treatment (Saraç vd. 2013) [76]. If used 1-4 times a week it is beneficial for treating gastrointestinal system disorders as well as being preventive for intestinal spasms, diabetes, hypertension, atherosclerosis, headache, abdominal pain, anemia, colds, flu, and rheumatism (Sargın et al. 2015) [77]. The roots are known to be used in rheumatical disorder treatment (Özdemir 2018) [50]. Young shoots may be eaten raw, but they are usually boiled and used in salads and omelets.

White Lupin - Termiye (Lupinus albus L.)

It can be used both medically and as food. White Lupin seeds are known to be anti-diabetic (int.) (Ivanova 2009) [78]. Drinking one cup of brewed and filtered White Lupin seeds in the morning is used for hypertension treatment (Birhanu 2011) [79]. Boiling White Lupin and rubbing the water all over sick animals’ skin is a treatment for parasites in domestic animals transmitted by pigs (Guarrera 1999.) [80] It is used as a protein-rich vegetable or savory dish. It can be used as a bean substitute, sautéed, or ground and mixed with flour to make bread. Sautéed, it can become a snack much like peanuts. An edible oil is obtained from the seed. Roasted and ground it can be used as a coffee substitute.

Foxtail Lily-Çiriş (Eremurus spectabilis M. Bieb.)

It can be used both medically and as food. It is used in traditional medicine in the treatment of hemorrhoids and diabetes and has urinary tract pain reliever and blood pressure lowering traits (Arı et al. 2014) [81]. It has also proven anti-inflammatory properties and potential, and its capacity to inhibit both hPBMC (in human peripheral blood mononuclear cell) proliferation and cytokine in vitro (Raffaella et al. 2015) [82]. If the above-ground parts of the plant are boiled and eaten, it helps digestion. Also, it can be consumed as a dish. The roots of the plant are crushed into a paste and applied to the head for headache and an ointment prepared from the plant’s root is used in scabies and syphilis treatment. (Baytop 1999) [43]. Young leaves are used as a vegetable for sautées mixed with yogurt and used to prepare main meals and omelets.

Crab Apple - At elması (Eriolobus trilobatus (Labill. ex Poiret) M. Roem.)

It is used in both food and medical industries.The results from the ethnobotanical documentation show that the fruits and leaves of crabapple are known to have natural antioxidant properties. They also contain important quantities of phenols and flavonoids. The amount of phenols contained in the flowers are comparable to Crataegus flowers and could be used for medical purposes. Further tests are needed (extraction solutes and chromatographic analyses) to support these results. Fruits can be used fresh or boiled (Çınar 2020) [83]. In Turkey, ethnobotanical work has shown that the species is used for intestinal disorders, obesity, rheumatism and heart diseases and eaten as fresh fruit, dried fruit, leaf/fruit herbal tea, pickle and fruit stew (Yılmaz and Ok 2012, Bulut 2006, Çınar and Göktürk 2019) [83-85].

Serik Pear- Zingit (Pyrus serikensis Güner & H. Duman)

Results from previous studies show that Pyrus serikensis extract is effective against plant pathogens (Kordali et al. 2009; Özcan et al. 2013; Bayar and Genç 2021) [77,86,87]. Serik pear fruit extracts have important antifungal activity and holds potential as an antimicrobial agent in alternative new drug therapies (Güven et al. 2006) [36]. Leaves and fruit extracts of P. Serikensis were found to have biofungicidal effects in plant pathogen control and can be used as a biopesticide. Its fruits can be consumed fresh or boiled.

Taro - Gölevez (Colocasia esculenta (L.) Schott)

It can be used both medically and as food. Taro has been shown effect to prevent the development of harmful bacteria in the intestine, to regulate the immune system, to increase mineral absorption, to accelerate blood flow in the colon. Taro’s anticarcinogenic, antiinflammatory effect has been reported. It has been reported in scientific studies that extracts obtained from taro inhibit certain tumor metastases strongly and specifically. Gastronomy and food industry have the potential to develop new products from taro which is a rich source of nutrition and has positive effects on health. Leaves and tubers of taro can be consumed. Taro tubers are blanched to cooked vegetables dishes. The leaves of taro are eaten as vegetables by people and also are regarded as wrapping and soup. The consumption of local in Turkey, taro tubers are blanched with meat. It is used as canned food, flour, chips, noodle and frozen food in tropical and subtropical countries. Dried fine powder of the taro tuber is used as thickening additives for bread, pastry, food and pasta. Mucilage of taro is added to diet products (Akgül et al. 2017) [88].

In the first stage of the research, information was given about edible medicinal plants in the region. In the second stage, the results of the survey conducted with consumers are given. According to these results; 61.5% of the people that has participated in the survey are men and 38.5% are women. 200 people who participated in the survey reside in 7 different districts of Antalya. The number of family members of the surveyed people varies between 1 and 6 people, and the most common family size is 4-person families with 42.4%. The average family size was calculated as 3.42. When the age groups of the people surveyed were examined, it was determined that the most common age group was between the ages of 31-40 (40.5%). When the educational status of the people participating in the survey is examined; It was determined that the majority of the people surveyed within the scope of the study had high school degree (27%) and university degree (47.5%) levels (Table 2).

Table 2: Socio-demographic characteristics of the people surveyed.

Gender of the people surveyed

 

Number of People

(%) Percentage

Male

123

61,5

Woman

77

38,5

Total

200

100,0

Districts where the interviewees resid

District

Number of People

(%) Percentage

Kepez

47

23,5

Muratpaşa

48

24,0

Konyaaltı

14

7,0

Döşemealtı

8

4,0

Elmalı

2

1,0

Aksu

1

,5

Serik

80

40,0

Total

200

100,0

Number of family members of interviewees

Number of Family Members

Number of People

(%) Percentage

1

8

4,0

2

34

17,0

3

52

26,0

4

85

42,5

5

11

5,5

6

10

5,0

Total

200

100,0

Age groups

Age group

Number of People

(%) Percentage

1-30

43

21,5

31-40

81

40,5

41-50

53

26,5

+50

23

11,5

 

200

100

Education status

Education status

Number of People

(%) Percentage

Literate

7

3,5

Primary School

21

10,5

Middle School

14

7,0

High School

54

27,0

University

95

47,5

Postgraduate

9

4,5

Total

200

100,0

         
 

The income of 44.5% of the individuals participating in the survey is between 1-20000 TL, and this income group has the highest percentage. The average monthly food expense of 48% of the survey participants is between 5 and 10 thousand liras. Regular and healthy nutrition is a situation that directly affects edible medicinal plant consumption habits. In this context, the respondents were asked about their regular diet. According to the results obtained, a large portion of the survey participants, 69%, stated that they eat healthy. (Chart 3).

Table 3: Average monthly income, food expenditure and nutritional status of respondents.

Average monthly income,

Income Group (TL)

Number of People

(%) Percentage

1-20000

89

44,5

20001-30000

58

29

30001-50000

40

20

+500000

13

7

Total

200

100,0

Average monthly food expenditure

Harcama Grubu(TL)

Number of People

(%) Percentage

1-5000

58

29

5001-10000

96

48

10001-20000

42

21

+20000

4

2

Total

200

100,0

Regular and healthy nutrition

Düzenli beslenme

Number of People

(%) Percentage

Yes

138

69,0

No

62

31,0

Total

200

100,0

 

Although the respondents' sources of information about edible plants are very different, the main sources of information are the internet, television, neighbors and market places (Table 4)

Table 4: News sources for information on edible medicinal plants.

Source of information

Yes

No

(%) Yes

(%) No

Internet

133

67

67

34

Television

118

82

59

41

Neighbors

108

92

54

46

Market

104

96

52

48

Brochures

97

103

49

52

Market

92

108

46

54

Newspaper

87

113

44

57

By sight during shoppi

85

115

43

58

Festival

85

115

43

58

Magazine

82

118

41

59

 

Within the scope of the project, the recognition of the plants identified in the region among the survey participants was examined and the results are given in Table 5. According to the results obtained, the most well-known edible medicinal plants among the survey participants are Elm-Leaved Sumach and Syrian Juniper (75%). Other plants known at high rates by respondents are Sorrel (73%), Asparagus (72%) and Watercress (70%). The least known edible plant species are; Calamus (27%), Çakşır (31%) and Gundelia (33%).

Table 5: Knowledge of which edible medicinal plants are known.

Edible medicinal plants

Yes

No

(%) Yes

(%) No

Elm Leaved Sumach-Sumak

150

50

75

25

Syrian Juniper-Andız

149

51

75

26

Kuzukemirdi (Kuzu kulağı)

145

54

73

27

Black Bryony-Kuşkonmaz

143

57

72

29

Watercress-Su teresi

140

60

70

30

White Lupin-Termiye (Tirmis)

129

71

65

36

Common chicory-Karahindiba

125

75

63

38

Caper Bush-Kapari

105

95

53

48

Serik Pear-Serik Armudu

101

99

51

50

Foxtail Lily-Çiriş

97

103

49

52

Salsify-Dedem sakalı

90

110

45

55

Arrost's baby's-breath-Çöğen

87

114

44

57

Crab Apple-At Elması

78

122

39

61

Berberis-Karamuk

78

122

39

61

Rush skeletonweed-Gara gavruk

74

126

37

63

Taro-Gölevez

73

127

37

64

Purple Salsify-Helevan (Yemlik)

73

127

37

64

Gundelia-Kenger

66

134

33

67

Ferula-Çakşır

61

139

31

70

Calamus-Eğir

53

147

27

74

 

Knowing the medicinal benefits of edible plants is the main factor affecting the consumption of these plants. Within the scope of the study, respondents were asked whether they knew the benefits of edible medicinal plants detected in the Mediterranean region. According to the results, the edible plants with the highest rate among plants with at least one known medicinal benefit are Syrian Juniper with 40% and Sumach with 35%. However, the data that has been obtained showed that the respondents did not know much about the medicinal benefits of these plants. (Table 6).

Table 6: Knowledge of the medicinal benefits of edible medicinal plants.

Edible medicinal plants

Yes

No

(%) Yes

(%) No

Elm Leaved Sumach-Sumak

79

121

40

61

Syrian Juniper-Andız

70

130

35

65

Kuzukemirdi (Kuzu kulağı)

54

146

27

73

Black Bryony-Kuşkonmaz

53

147

27

74

Watercress-Su teresi

48

152

24

76

White Lupin-Termiye (Tirmis)

45

155

23

78

Common chicory-Karahindiba

44

156

22

78

Caper Bush-Kapari

42

158

21

79

Serik Pear-Serik Armudu

42

158

21

79

Foxtail Lily-Çiriş

41

159

21

80

Salsify-Dedem sakalı

40

160

20

80

Arrost's baby's-breath-Çöğen

38

162

19

81

Crab Apple-At Elması

32

168

16

84

Berberis-Karamuk

31

169

16

85

Rush skeletonweed-Gara gavruk

30

170

15

85

Taro-Gölevez

23

177

12

89

Purple Salsify-Helevan (Yemlik)

22

178

11

89

Gundelia-Kenger

22

178

11

89

Ferula-Çakşır

20

180

10

90

Calamus-Eğir

20

180

10

90

 

 

Another important reason affecting the consumption of edible plants is the accessibility of the market for these plants. In this context, the respondents were asked whether there was a place where they could reach and purchase one or more of these plants in the environment where they live or work, and the data obtained is given in Table 7. While only 27.5% of the respondents have access to some of these plants, 72.5% do not have a farmer’s market around them where they can access these plants, although they have the desire to buy them. While 51.5% of the survey participants purchased at least one of the plants identified, 48.5% did not purchase any of these plants. Respondents were asked whether they would want to buy edible medicinal plants growing in the Mediterranean region if they knew their benefits and side effects. The majority of the respondents (80.5%) stated that they could buy and consume these plants after being informed about the benefits and side effects of the plants, while the remaining part (19.5%) stated that they would not buy and consume these plants even if they were informed.

Table 7: Request for sale and purchase of edible medicinal plants.

Availability of places selling these plants in the immediate vicinity

Location status

Number of People

(%) Percentage

Yes

55

27,5

No

145

72,5

Total

200

100,0

Purchasing status of edible medicinal plants

Are you buying it?

Number of People

(%) Percentage

Yes

103

51,5

No

97

48,5

Total

200

100,0

Willingness to buy edible medicinal plants if they know their benefits and side effects

I buy

Number of People

(%) Percentage

Yes

161

80,5

No

39

19,5

Total

200

100,0

         
 

The main reasons for the group who are reluctant to purchase medicinal plants are that the prices of these plants are high, they are not reliable, they are not suitable for their consumption habits, they do not know their benefits, and they prefer to use medicine instead of consuming these plants (Chart 8).

Table 8: Reasons not to buy edible medicinal plants.

Reasons

 

Mean

 

Standard Deviation

High price

2,27

1,011

Lack of reliability

2,40

1,032

Not suitable for consumption habits

2,41

,920

Not knowing the benefits

2,44

1,011

I prefer to take medicine

2,48

1,012

Not believing in quality

2,50

,935

Not preferred by family members

2,53

,935

Not knowing the side effects

2,54

,934

Unknown medical effects

2,54

,990

Considered to be harmful to healthExpensive compared to medicines

2,56

,949

Low nutritional value

2,60

,967

Inappropriate storage location and conditions

2,62

1,000

Lack of knowledge about the product

2,63

1,020

Lack of flavor

2,63

1,004

I don't know enough

2,64

,982

I don't know how to consume

2,66

1,132

The taste is not pleasant

2,66

1,096

The weight of the packaging is not appropriate

2,69

1,025

High price

2,74

1,030

 

Scale: 1: Very important, 2: Important, 3: Neutral, 4: Not important, 5: Not important at all

Those who participated in the survey and consumed at least one of these plants were asked how they accessed edible medicinal plants and the results are shown in Table 9. 28% of these people buy all the plants they consume, 25% buy the majority part of the plants they consume, 19% mostly collect them from nature, 3.5% collect all the plants they consume from nature, and 24% obtains these plants from their neighbors and relatives.

Table 9: Availability of edible medicinal plants consumed.

Availability

Mean

Standard Deviation

I buy the whole thing

57

28,5

I buy mostly

50

25,0

Mostly I collect it myself

38

19,0

I collect it all myself

7

3,5

I get it from my neighbors or relatives

48

24,0

Total

200

100,0

 

Within the scope of the research, the respondents were asked how much of the edible medicinal plants growing in the Mediterranean region they consumed annually, and the results are given in Table 10. According to this data, the edible medicinal plants that are mostly consumed are Capers, Rush skeletonweed, White Lupin, and Watercress, while the least consumed plants are Arrost’s Bay’s Breath, Gundelia, and Berberis.

Table 10: Annual consumption of edible medicinal plants consumed.

Consumption of Medicinal Plants

Amount (kg/year)

Elm Leaved Sumach-Sumak

10,63

Syrian Juniper-Andız

6,63

Kuzukemirdi (Kuzu kulağı)

5,83

Black Bryony-Kuşkonmaz

5,74

Watercress-Su teresi

4,69

White Lupin-Termiye (Tirmis)

4,27

Common chicory-Karahindiba

3,04

Caper Bush-Kapari

2,86

Serik Pear-Serik Armudu

2,85

Foxtail Lily-Çiriş

2,82

Salsify-Dedem sakalı

2,79

Arrost's baby's-breath-Çöğen

2,78

Crab Apple-At Elması

2,58

Berberis-Karamuk

2,44

Rush skeletonweed-Gara gavruk

1,63

Taro-Gölevez

1,61

Purple Salsify-Helevan (Yemlik)

1,60

Gundelia-Kenger

1,52

Ferula-Çakşır

1,48

Calamus-Eğir

1,35

 

Survey participants make their decisions based on certain reasons when deciding to purchase edible medicinal plants. The most important reasons why the survey participants buy these plants are that these plants are healthy, delicious, natural and have high nutritional values (Table 11). People who consume these plants choose plants to buy and consume by paying attention to the freshness of the product, whether it is an organic product or not, the price level and the quality of the product (Table 11).

Table 11: The most important reason or reasons for respondents to purchase edible medicinal plant.

Reasons

 

Mean

 

Standard Deviation

Good health

1,45

1,01

Being delicious

1,83

1,21

Being natural

1,84

1,27

Nutritional value

1,88

1,23

No additives

1,89

1,24

Ease of preparation

1,97

1,14

Reliable and hygienic

1,97

1,18

Diversity

1,98

1,17

Family members like it

2,02

1,19

More effective than medicines

2,07

1,25

Availability in all seasons

2,09

1,23

Economical compared to pharmaceuticals

2,09

1,27

Advice from the environment

2,16

1,33

Habit

2,20

1,27

 

Scale: 1: Very important, 2: Important, 3: Neutral, 4: Not important, 5: Not important at all

Table 12: Qualities that are important when buying edible medicinal plants.

Qualities

Mean

Standard Deviation

Product Freshness

1,73

1,19

Organic Product

1,78

1,17

Price Level

1,85

1,32

Product Odor

1,91

1,19

Product Quality

1,91

1,31

Nutritional Value

1,95

1,26

Product Appearance

1,98

1,24

Easy to access

2,08

1,30

Product Size

2,35

1,33

Product Color

2,37

1,41

 

Scale: 1: Very important, 2: Important, 3: Neutral, 4: Not important, 5: Not important at all

The data obtained in the study and stated previously show that at least one or more of the edible medicinal plants were purchased and consumed by the respondents. However, consumption amounts were quite low. In this context, the respondents were asked the question "If which conditions are met or changed, consumption amounts of these plants may increase." According to the results obtained, consumers stated that this could increase their consumption if their income increases, if these plants are more easily found and accessible, if they are pre-cleaned and packaged reliably, and if the level of knowledge about the plant increases (Chart 13).

 

Table 13: Factors that will influence your future purchase of medicinal plants.

Factors

Mean

Standard Deviation

If income increases

1,55

1,00

If it is easy to find

1,65

1,03

Reliable packaging-cleaning processes

1,66

1,09

Increased product awareness

1,67

1,13

If the preparation is known

1,72

1,07

If the product range expands

1,73

1,12

If the price is right

1,73

1,04

If adequate information is provided

1,74

1,14

If medical effects are proven

1,75

1,19

 

Scale: 1: Very important, 2: Important, 3: Neutral, 4: Not important, 5: Not important at all

Consumers act according to their priorities when choosing the products they consume. These include qualitative or quantitative features such as the product being healthy, having a low price, etc. In this context, consumption preferences of edible medicinal plants are based on various factors. Consumers participating in the survey act according to different factors when deciding to purchase or consume medicinal plants. The most important of these were determined as factors such as nutritional value, product cleanliness, price level, product being organic, availability and product freshness (Table 14).

Table 14: Comparison of medicinal plant consumption preference in terms of various characteristics.

Consumption Preferences

Mean

Standard Deviation

Nutritional value

1,81

1,08

Product Cleaning

1,83

1,12

Price level

1,84

1,01

Organic Product

1,85

1,12

AvailabilityProduct freshness

1,86

1,16

Certified

1,90

1,13

Smell of the productAvailability

1,91

1,15

Organic product range

1,92

1,08

Product quality

1,94

1,15

Proximity (home)

1,95

1,13

Medical value

1,96

1,15

Product diversity

1,97

1,08

Payment alternatives

1,98

1,07

Receiving in the desired weight

2,00

1,03

Product awareness

2,03

1,14

The product is packaged

2,04

1,14

Price reductions

2,04

1,16

Habit

2,04

1,07

Product display

2,05

1,11

Shopping environment

2,05

1,18

Skilled salesperson

2,06

1,16

Product appearance

2,07

1,44

Friendly salesperson

2,07

1,12

Promotion activities

2,09

1,20

Product color

2,12

1,21

Salesperson persuasion skills

2,12

1,16

Size of the product

2,13

1,14

Helpful salesperson

2,16

1,19

Bulk shopping

2,18

1,18

Salesperson who can provide information

2,19

1,20

Sufficient sales staff

2,20

1,26

Nutritional value

2,21

1,22

Product Cleaning

2,31

1,23

 

Scale 1: Very important, 2: Important, 3: Neutral, 4: Not important, 5: Not important at all.

Within the scope of the research, a factor analysis was conducted on the factors affecting edible medicinal plant consumption in order to make the edible medicinal plant consumption preferences of the consumers participating in the survey more explainable and meaningful. Initially, a reliability analysis was performed and the Cronbach alpha value was calculated as 0.899. In factor analysis, eigenvalue??? was taken as the criterion in determining the number of factors. Accordingly, six factors with eigenvalues above one were found. These factors explain 77.89% of the total variance. Factor weights obtained as a result of factor analysis are given in Table 15. The obtained factors are named as following according to the subjects and characteristics of the sub-factors that make up these factors;

Factor 1: Information and accessibility; The sub-factors that make up this factor consists of factors such as proving the benefits of edible medicinal plants, obtaining information from written and visual media, health properties, knowing their effects, etc.

Factor 2: Marketing; The sub-factors of this factor basically consist of sub-factors such as the way edible medicinal plants are introduced to the market, packaging, pricing and storage conditions.

Factor 3: Healthy nutrition; The third factor obtained as a result of the analysis is based on the association of edible medicinal plants with healthy nutrition. The sub-factors in this group are sub-factors that feature regular and healthy nutrition.

Factor 4: Taste and benefit; This factor, which affects consumers' edible medicinal plant consumption habits, is specific to the fact that edible plants are delicious, healthy and beneficial to human health.

Factor 5: Brand and awareness; This factor refers to the fact that the benefits of edible medicinal plants are better known by the public, as well as the impact that these plants will have on the consumer through branding.

Factor 6: Type of cultivation; This factor shows that the way edible medicinal plants are grown can directly affect the consumption of these plants. The sub-factors that make up these factors are; Factors that consumers pay attention to when purchasing and choosing to consume these plants are the region where the plant is grown, the way it is grown, whether it is domestic production or imported production.

Table 15: Factor analysis results of the respondents' consumption of edible medicinal plants.

F

Consumer preferences for edible medicinal plants

Factors

1

2

3

4

5

6

1

Scientific proof of side effects of medicinal plants is important to me

,820

         

I follow the written/visual media on health etc. related to medicinal plants.

,787

         

The packages of the medicinal plants I buy should have information on their health properties

,779

         

It is important to consume medicinal plants carefully.

,744

         

It is very important for me to know the scientific effects of the medicinal plants I buy.

,740

         

It is important that the benefits of medicinal plants are scientifically proven

,712

         

The smell of the medicinal plants I buy is very important to me. The appearance of the medicinal plants I buy is very important to me.

,630

         

Scientific proof of side effects of medicinal plants is important to me

,445

         

2

It is important that the medicinal plants I buy are reliable.

 

-,839

       

I prefer to consume medicinal plants instead of medicines

 

-,806

       

It is very important for me that medicinal plants are not expensive.

 

,859

 

 

 

 

It is important to know the storage methods of medicinal plants.

 

-,775

       

The medicinal plants I buy should be packaged

 

,766

       

I spend a long time shopping for medicinal plants and make careful choices.

 

-,762

       

The medicinal plants I want to consume should be sold close to my home. Price is not important for me when buying medicinal plants.

 

,547

       

The packaging material of the medicinal plants I buy is important

 

-,726

       

The medicinal plants I will buy must have appropriate storage conditions.

 

-,611

       

The package size of the medicinal plants I will buy is not important.

 

-,564

       

Packaging waste of medicinal plants should not harm the environment.

 

-,537

       

It is important that the medicinal plants I buy are reliable.

 

-,497

       

3

I make sure to eat three meals a day without skipping meals

   

,301

     

Medicinal plants are healthier than other foods.

 

 

,733

     

I always research the side effects of medicinal plants I am considering buying

   

,563

     

Our family has a habit of eating breakfast regularly.

   

,553

     

I always research the effects of the medicinal plants I plan to buy

   

,551

     

Regular nutrition is important to me.

   

,542

     

4

I make sure that the plant I buy has health benefits.

     

1,007

   

The medicinal plants I consume should help me relax and calm down.

     

,995

   

The flavor of the medicinal plants I buy is important to me.

 

 

 

-,594

 

 

5

I prefer imported medicinal plants.

       

,882

 

I prefer medicinal plants to be branded.

       

,574

 

I generally find what the public says about the benefits of medicinal plants exaggerated.

       

,546

 

When consuming medicinal plants, I take into account what is said by the public about their benefits

       

,521

 

6

The way medicinal plants are grown is important to me (natural environment, greenhouse, open field, etc.)

         

-,360

I prefer that the plants I will buy are locally produced.

         

-,331

Production of medicinal plants should be expanded

         

-,642

It is important to me that the medicinal plants I buy are organic.

         

-,448

The place where medicinal plants are grown is important for me (Region)

         

-,421

KMO and Bartlett's Test

Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of Sampling Adequacy.

,899

Bartlett's Test of Sphericity

Approx. Chi-Square

9863,298

df

861

Sig.

,000

                   

 

CONCLUSION

The use of wild plants as medicine and food by the Anatolian people dates to ancient times. (Akgün et al. 2004) [88].

The diversity of wild edible plants are laden with nutrients and bioactive compounds which have immense potential for providing nutritional security and health benefits. They are an important source of food for the indigenous people and are also used in the traditional system of medicine.

The sine qua non of long and healthy life, Mediterranean-type nutrition has stood out as humanity grasped the importance of healthy nutrition. Mediterranean-type nutrition, which has dominated most of the Turkish cuisine due to its geographic location, has its basis in wild plants and plant dishes (Kılıç 2010) [89].

A new interest and curiosity has arisen towards traditional medicine globally. It has been reported that traditional medicine forms 40% of all healthcare services in China and similar medical practices are performed by 71% of the Chilean population and 40% of the Colombian population. 65% of the population living in rural India uses traditional medicine techniques to meet their basic healthcare needs (Öztürk et al. 2005) [90]. Another reason for the increasing importance of medicinal plants is resistant variants developed by disease agents. Due to the versatile effects of preparations made from medicinal plants, they are found to have an effect against new strains. Because of these reasons, there has been a return to herbal preparations. Malaria is as an example. Even though synthetic preparations such as Atabrine are used for malaria treatment, Quinine obtained from the chinchona tree which grows in the tropics still carries great importance (Ceylan 1995) [91].

Singular grouping in trade statistics is out of the question because of the amount and vast variety of active ingredients obtained from medicinal and aromatic plants in trade. Most healthy and trustable information about world trade volume and value of medicinal and aromatic plants can be obtained from the Data Base of the International Trade Center in Geneva (UN Comtrade). In the last 5 years worldwide herbal drug trade was estimated at 16,8 million dollars in exportation and 18,6 million dollars in importation. The most important plant varieties in terms of production are onion-tuber, tea, coffee, spice, seasoning, root and other plant groups. The countries that import medicinal and aromatic plants in the world are America, the United Kingdom, Germany, France, Netherlands. China and India also export a vast variety of plants. On the other hand, changing health conception in developed countries has increased the use of plants that add flavors to dishes due to decreasing unhealthy components of food like salt and oil (Binici 2002) [92].

There are 374 imported and exported plant species in Turkey that are collected from nature, with a 30% expotation rate (Özhatay and Koyuncu 1997) [93]. The important medicinal and spice plants exported by Turkey are thyme, bay leaves, cumin, anise, fennel seeds, juniper bark, st lucie cherry, fenugreek, rosemary, licorice root, mint, sumac, sage and linden flowers (Bayram et al. 2010) [94].

Plant derived natural bioactive compounds are a valuable source for drug development and in recent years, they have been approved by Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for development of modern drugs.

Wild edible plants, which are assessed as plants should be consumed for their vitamin, flavinoid, antioxidant, fiber, and microelement components as healthy, nutritious and protective foods. In our country, it is aimed to protect public health through regulations and laws (Turkish Food Codex Regulation on Addition of Vitamins, Minerals and Certain Other Elements to Foods, Date: 07-03-2017, Number: 30000 and Turkish Food Codex Notification on Food Supplements - Number: 28737, Date :16/8/2013) regulations regarding the use of bioactive compounds have been made and studies on this subject continue.

The health importance of edible wild plants has been increasing against rising nutrition problems because of the fast overpopulation. Also, when wild plants are medically assessed they provide a substantial amoung of active ingredients for drugs used for human and animal health. For these reasons, to maintain a healthy diet as well as to provide balanced nutrition, plant dishes should be included in the menus.

As a result of this study, it was determined that the edible medicinal plants found to grow in the Mediterranean region are not well known by consumers and consumers' knowledge about the benefits and harms of these plants is not sufficient. Consumers stated that they could consume these plants if they were informed about the benefits and side effects of these plants and if the prices of the plants were affordable.

Consuming edible herbs has now become one of the habits given up by people who migrated to the city, in parallel with urbanization. Over time, people have come to know only cultivated herbs because they are not in touch with nature. Herbs that grow spontaneously in nature are no longer consumed by young people in cities and even in the regions where they grow. Recently, steps have been taken to change this situation. In particular, people have become curious to know what edible wild plants are, how they are consumed, their taste, how they are cooked, and the benefits of herbs. This being the case, medicinal edible plants have begun to be seen, albeit to a small extent, in many different places such as restaurant menus, festivals, events, and street markets. This situation will also change consumer behavior towards edible medicinal plants over time. In this study, important results were obtained in terms of consumer behavior regarding edible medicinal plants.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

This study was part of Biodiversity for Food and Nutrition (BFN) Project funded by the Global Environment Fund - GEF (United Nations Environment Programme - UNEP&Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations-FAO).

REFERENCES

  1. Davis, F. D. (1985). A Technology Acceptance Model for Empirically Testing New End-User Information Systems: Theory and Results. Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
  2. Güner A. (2012). Türkiye Bitkiler Listesi Damarlı Bitkileri, Nezahat Gökyiğit Botanik Bahçesi Yayınları, İstanbul
  3. Ekim T, Koyuncu M, Erik S, İlarslan R. (1989). Türkiye’nin Nadir ve Endemik Bitkilerinin “Red Data Book” Kategorilerine Göre Sınıflandırılması. Türkiye Tabiatını Koruma Derneği, Yayın no:18.
  4. Erik S, Tarıkahya B. (2004). Türkiye Florası Üzerine, Kebikeç. 17:139-163.
  5. Ekim, T., & Güner, A. (2000). The floristic richness of Turkey. Curtis's Botanical Magazine, 17(2), 48-59.
  6. Baytop T. (1999). Türkiye'de bitkiler ile tedavi: geçmişte ve bugün. Nobel Tıp Kitabevleri
  7. Aydın, S. (2004). Anadolu Diyagonali: ekolojik kesinti tarihsel-kültürel bir farklılığa işaret edebilir mi. Kebikeç İnsan Bilimleri için Kaynak Araştırmaları Dergisi, 17, 117-137.
  8. Anonymous. (1997). Erozyona karşı köklü çözüm Kapari (Gebere). Orman Bakanlığı, AGM Yayınları. 2:47.
  9. Karabak S. (2017). Economic and Socio-Cultural Importance of Edible Wild Species, ANADOLU, J. of AARI. 2):26- 38
  10. Ayas F, Vuran, FA Yuksel K Çınar O, Tugrul Ay S, Karabak S. (2022). The Antioxidant Capacities and Consumption per Capita of Edible Wild Species and Local Varieties Collected from Turkey within the GEF-funded Biodiversity for Food and Nutrition (BFN) Project. ANADOLU Ege Tarımsal Arastırma Enstitüsü Derg. 27:46–53.
  11. Hair J, Anderson R, Tatham R, Black W. (1998). Multivariate data analysis, Prentice Hall, New Jersey.
  12. Oppenheim AN. (1992). Questionnaire Design, Interviewing and Attitude Measurement, Continuum, London.
  13. Palani S, Raja S, Pravin S, Kumar K, Devi B, Kumar S. (2009). Therapeutic efficacy of antihepatotoxic and antioxidant activities Acarus calamus on acetaminophen induced toxicity in rat. January. Int J Integrative Biol. 7(1).
  14. Devi A, Ganjewala DS. (2011). Antioxidant Activities of Methanolic Extracts of Sweet Flag Leaves and Rhizomes J Herbs Spices Med plants. 17:1-11.
  15. Singh R, Sharma PR, Malviya R. (2011). Pharmacological Properties and Ayurvedic Value of Indian Buch Plant (Acorus calamus): A Short Review. Adv Biol Res. 5 (3):148.
  16. Mehrotra S, Mishra KP, Maurya R, Srimal RC, Yadav VS, Pandey R, et al. (2003) Anticellular and immunosuppressive properties of ethanolic extract of Acoruscalamus rhizome. 3(1):53-61.
  17. Tuzlacı E. (2006). Şifa Niyetine Türkiye' nin Bitkisel Halk İlaçları. Alfa Yayıncılık, İstanbul.
  18. Tuzlacı E. (2011) Türkiye Bitkileri Sözlüğü. Alfa Yayıncılık, İstanbul.
  19. Ali-Shtayeh, MS, Al-Assali, AA, Jamous RM. (2013). Antimicrobial activity of Palestinian medicinal plants against acne-inducing bacteria. African J Microbiol Res. 7:2560- 2573.
  20. Setorki M, Rafieian M, Heidarian E, Ghatreh K, Shahinfard N, Ansari R, et al. (2012) Effect of Rhus coriaria consumption with high cholesterol food on some atherosclerosis risk factors in rabbit. J Babol Univ Med Sci. 14:38-45.
  21. Hasanova,G, Öztürk M, Akçiçek E. (2000). Azerbaycan' da Geleneksel Tedavide Kullanılan Bitkiler 13. BİHAT özet kitabı, İstanbul.
  22. Akan H. (2015). Kahta (Adıyaman) merkezi ve Narince köyünün etnobotanik açıdan araştırılması. Bitlis Eren Üniversitesi Fen Bilimleri Dergisi. 4(2).
  23. Kocabaş YZ, Gedik O. (2016). Kahramanmaraş il merkezi semt pazarlarında satılan bitkiler hakkında etnobotanik araştırmalar. Iğdır Üniversitesi Fen Bilimleri Enstitüsü Dergisi. 6(4):41-50.
  24. Eser N, Yoldaş A, Yigin A, Yumusak N, Bozkurt AS, Kokbas U, et al. (2020). The protective effect of Ferula elaeochytris on age-related erectile dysfunction. J Ethnopharmacol. 258:112921.
  25. Akbulut S. (2015). Differences in the traditional use of wild plants between rural and urban areas: the sample of Adana. Stud Ethno-Med. 9(2):141-150.
  26. Sargin SA, Büyükcengiz M. (2019). Plants used in ethnomedicinal practices in Gulnar district of Mersin, Turkey. J Herbal Med. 15:100224.
  27. Akalın E, Alpınar K. (1994). Tekirdağ’ın tıbbi ve yenen bitkileri hakkında bir araştırma; Ege Ünv Ecz Fak Derg. 2(1):1-11.
  28. Özhatay N, Akalın E. (1998). Türkiye’nin batısında yetişen Ferulago türleri üzerinde taksonomik araştırmalar. Tübitak.
  29. Şatır E. (2006). Ferulago platycarpa Boiss. &Bal. Üüzerinde Farmasötik Botanik Yönünden Araştırmalar. A.Ü. Sağlık Bilimleri Enstitüsü, Yüksek Lisans Tezi, 2006, Ankara (Danışman: Prof. Dr. M Coşkun).
  30. Araceli AQ, Jose P, Jose D. (1999). Antitumoral of Pyrimidine derivatives of Phytochemical sesquiterpen lactones. J Pharm Pharmaceut Sci. 3:108-112.
  31. Hazra B, Sarkar R., Bhattacharyya S, Roy P. (2002). Tumour inhibitory activity of chicory root extract against Ehrlich ascites carcinoma in mice. Fitoterapia. 73:730-733.
  32. Bremness L. (1998) The Complete Book of Herbs of Joanna Chisholm (Eds.), Darling Kindersley, London:68.
  33. Bischoff TA, Kelley CJ, Karchesy Y, Laurantos M, Nguyen-Dinh P, Arefi AG. (2004). Antimalarial activity of Lactucin and Lactucopicrin sesquiterpene lactones isolated from Cichorium I ntybus L. J Ethnopharmacol. 95:455-457.
  34. Monde KT, Oya A, Shira, Takasugi M. (1990). A guaianolids phytoalexin, cichorelaxin from Cichorium intybus, Phytochem. 29:3449-3451.
  35. Nishmura H, Nagasaka T, Satoh A. (1999). Ecochemical from chicory rhizome, Academia Sinica. 2:63-70.
  36. Güven K, Yücel E, Çetintaş F. (2006). Antimicrobial Activities of Fruits of Crataegus and Pyrus. Species Pharm Biol. 44(2):79–83.
  37. Chopra RN, Nayar SL, Chopra IC. (2002). The glossary of Indian medicinal plants, CSIR, New Delhi.44.
  38. Şenkardeş İ. (2014). Nevşehirin güney ilçelerinde (Acıgöl, Derinkuyu, Gülşehir, Nevşehir-Merkez, Ürgüp) etnobotanik araştırmalar.
  39. Çakılcıoğlu U, Türkoğlu İ. (2009). Çitli Ovası (Elazığ) ve çevresinin etnobotanik özellikleri. J New World Sci Academy Ecol Life Sci. 4(2):81-85.
  40. Uzun M. (2015). İnönü ve Mihalgazi (Eskişehir) ilçe ve köylerinde etnobotanik araştırmalar (Master's thesis, Anadolu Üniversitesi).
  41. Deniz L Serteser A, KARGIOĞLU M. (2010). Uşak Üniversitesi ve yakın çevresindeki bazı bitkilerin mahalli adları ve etnobotanik özellikleri. Afyon Kocatepe Üniversitesi Fen Ve Mühendislik Bilimleri Dergisi. 10(1):57-72.
  42. Tsevegsuren N, Edrada RA, Lin W, Ebel R, Torre C, Ortlepp S, Wray V, Proksch P. (2007). Four New Natural Products from Mongolian Medicinal Plants Scorzonera divaricata and Scorzonera pseudodivaricata (Asteraceae), Planta Med. 72:962-967.
  43. Baytop T. (1999). Therapy with medicinal plants in Turkey (past and present) Nobel Tıp Kitapevleri: Istanbul:152–153.
  44. Zidorn C, Ellmerer-Müller EP, Stuppner H. (2000). Sesquiterpenoids from Scorzonera hispanica L. Pharmazie. 55:550-551.
  45. Sezik E, Yeşilada E, Tabata M, Honda G, Takaishi Y, Fujita T, et al. (1997). Traditional medicine in Turkey VIII. Folk medicine in East Anatolia; Erzurum, Erzincan, Agn, Kars, Iğdır Provinces. Econ Bot. 51:195-211.
  46. Bahadır 0. (2009). Pharmacognostical Studies on Some Scorzonera Species Growing In Turkey, PhD Thesis, Ankara University Faculty of Pharmacy.
  47. Siintar İ, Acıkara Bahadır Ö, Çitoğlu Saltan G, Keles H, Ergene B, Kiipeli Akkol E, et al. (2012) In vivo and in vitro Evaluation of the Therapeutic Potential of Some Scorzonera Species as Wound healing Agent. Curr Pharm Desing. 18:1421-1433.
  48. Tunon H, Olavsdotter C, Bohlin L. (1995) Evaluation of anti-inflammatory activity of some Swedish medicinal plants. Inhibition of prostaglandin biosynthesis and PAF-induced exocytosis. J Ethnopharmacol. 48(2):61–76.
  49. Formisano C, Rigano D, Senatore F, Bruno M, Rosselli S. (2010). Volatile constituents of the aerial parts of white salsify (Tragopogon porrifolius L., Asteraceae). Nat Prod Res. 24:663-668.
  50. Öztürk, M., Uskun, E., Özdemir, R., Çınar, M., Alptekin, F., & Doğan, M. (2005). Isparta ilinde halkın geleneksel tedavi tercihi. Turkiye Klinikleri J Med Ethics, 13(3), 179-86. Konopiński M. (2009). Influence of intercrop plants and varied tillage on yields and nutritional value of salsify (Tragopogon porrifolius L.) roots. Acta Sci Pol Hortorum Cultus. 8:27-36.
  51. Lyons CP. (1956). Trees, Shrubs and Flowers to Know in Washington (1st ed.). Canada: J. M. Dent & Sons:153-196.
  52. Heistinger A. (2013). The manual of seed saving: harvesting, storing and sowing techniques for vegetables, herbs and fruits. London: Timber Press Portland.
  53. Niering W, Olmstead NC. (1979). The Audubon Society Field Guide to North American Wildflowers, Eastern Region. Knopf:404.
  54. Turan M, Kordali S, Zengin H, Dursun A, Sezen Y. (2003). Macro, Micro Mineral Content of Some edible Leaves Consumed in Eastern Anatolia. Acta Agr Scand B-S P. 53:129-137.
  55. Tuzlacı E. (2016). Türkiye bitkileri geleneksel ilaç rehberi. İstanbul Tıp Kitabevleri, İstanbul.
  56. Gedikli F. (2006). Ceviz (Juglans regia), karadut (Morus nigra), karamuk (Berberis crataegina), kök boya (Rubia tinctorum) ve kızılağaç (Alnus glutinosa) nın protein elektroforez jellerinin boyanmasında kullanılabilirliğinin araştırılması (Master's thesis, Fen Bilimleri Enstitüsü).
  57. Yeşilada E, Küpeli E. (2002). Berberis crataegina DC. root exhibits potent anti-inflammatory, analgesic and febrifuge effects in mice and rats. J Ethnopharmacol: 79(2):237-248.
  58.  Cansaran, A., Kaya, Ö. F., & Yıldırım, C. (2007). Ovabaşı, Akpınar, Güllüce ve Köseler köyleri (Gümüşhacıköy/Amasya) arasında kalan bölgede etnobotanik bir araştırma. Fırat Üniversitesi Fen ve Mühendislik Bilimleri Dergisi, 19(3), 243-257.
  59. Borelli T, Güzelsoy NA, Hunter D,Tan A, Karabak S, Uçurum HÖ, et al. (2022). Assessment of the Nutritional Value of Selected Wild Food Plants in Türkiye and Their Promotion for Improved Nutrition. Sustainability. 14:11015.
  60. Everest A, Oztürk E. (2005). Focussing on the Ethnobotanical Uses of Plants in Mersin and Adana Provinces (Turkey). J Ethnobiol Ethnomed. 1:1-6.
  61. Özer Z, Önen H, Tursun N, Uygur FN. (1999). Türkiye’nin Bazı Önemli Yabancı Otları. Gaziosmanpaşa Üniversitesi, Ziraat Fakültesi Yayınları, No:38 Kitap seri No:16, Tokat, Türkiye:434.
  62. Argentieri M, Macchia F, Papadia P, Fanizzi FP, Avato P. (2012) Bioactive compounds from Capparis spinosa subsp rupestris. Ind Crop Prod. 36(1):65-69.
  63. Singh P, Mishra G, Srivastava S, Shruti Jha KKLKR. (2011) Traditional uses, phytochemistry and pharmacological properties of Capparis decidua: An Overview. Pharm Lett. 3(2):71-82.
  64. Tlili N, Khaldi A, Triki S, Munne-Bosch S. (2010). Phenolic Compounds and Vitamin Antioxidants of Caper (Capparis spinosa). Plant Food Hum Nutr. 65(3):260-265.
  65. Huseini HF, Hasani-Rnjbar S, Nayebi N, Heshmat R, Sigaroodi FK, Ahvazi M, et al. (2013). Capparis spinosa L. (Caper) fruit extract in treatment of type 2 diabetic patients: A randomized double-blind placebo-controlled clinical trial. Complement Ther Med. 21(5):447-452.
  66. Tanker N, Koyuncu M, Coşkun M. (1998) Farmasötik Botanik, Ankara Üniversitesi, Eczacılık Fakültesi Yayınları, Ders Kitapları No:78, Ankara Üniversitesi Basımevi, Ankara.
  67. Öztürk A, Öztürk S, Kartal Ş. (2000). Van Otlu Peynirlerine Katılan Bitkilerin Özellikleri ve Kullanılışları.  OT Sistematik Botanik Dergisi. 7(2):167–179.
  68. Velioğlu S. (2001). Çöven Ekstraktı Üretim Koşullarının Belirlenmesi ve Standardize Edilmesi Üzerine Araştırma, TÜBİTAK, Tarım Ormancılık ve Gıda Teknolojileri Araştırma Grubu (TOGTAG), Proje No: 2467.
  69. Mascolo N, Autore G, Capasso F, Menghini A, Fasulo MP. (1987). Biological screening of Italian medicinal plants for anti-inflammatory activity. Phytother Res. 1:28–31.
  70. Tilford Gregory L (1998) Mountain Press Publishing Company; 1997. Edible and Medicinal Plants of the West.
  71. McCabe M, Gohdes D, Morgan F. (2005). Herbal therapies among Navajo Indians. Diabetes Care. 28(6):1534–1535.
  72. Pepeljnjak S, Kosalec I, Kalodera Z, Blǎzevíc N. (2005). Antimicrobial activity of juniper berry essential oil Juniperus communis L., Cupressaceae. Acta Pharm. 55(4):417–422.
  73. Gumral N, Kumbul DD, Aylak F, Saygin M, Savik E. (2013). Juniperus communis Linn oil decreases oxidative stress and increases antioxidant enzymes in the heart of rats administered a diet rich in cholesterol. Toxicol. Ind. Health. 31(1):85–91.
  74. Filipowicz N, Kamiński M, Kurlenda J, Asztemborska M, Ochocka JR. (2003). Antibacterial and antifungal activity of juniper berry oil and its selected components. Phytother Res. 17(3):227–231.
  75. Pathak S, Tewari RK, Prakash AO. (1990). Hormonal properties of ethanolic extract of Juniperus communis linn. Ancient Sci Life. 10(2):106–113. 
  76. Saraç DU, Özkan ZC, Akbulut S. (2013). Ethnobotanic features of Rize/Turkey province. Biol Diver Conser. 6(3):57-66
  77. Sargin SA, Selvi S, López V. (2015). Ethnomedicinal plants of sarigöl district (Manisa), Turkey. J Ethnopharmacol. 171:64-84.
  78. Ivanova D. (2009). Plant, fungal and. by Institute of Botany, Bulgarian Academy of Sciences.
  79. Birhanu Z. (2011). Ethno-botanical survey on medicinal plants used by ethnic groups of Denbia district, north-western Ethiopia. J Nat Remed. 11(2):119-123.
  80. Guarrera PM. (1999). Traditional antihelmintic, antiparasitic and repellent uses of plants in Central Italy. J Ethnopharmacol. 68(1-3):183-192.
  81. Arı S, Temel M, Kargıoğlu M, Konuk M. (2015). Ethnobotanical survey of plants used in Afyonkarahisar-Turkey. J Ethnobiol Ethnomed. 11(1).
  82. Raffaella G, Daniela R, Karzan M. Davide G, Barbara M, Federica C, et al. (2015). Towards elucidating Eremurus root remedy: Chemical profiling and preliminary biological investigations of Eremurus persicus and Eremurus spectabilis root ethanolic extracts. J MedPlants Res. 9(41):1038-1048.
  83. Çınar N Göktürk RS, Öten M. (2020). Some Medicinal Propertıes Of Crab Apple (Eriolobus trilobatus) Genotypes In Antalya Provınce. Res J Biol Sci. 13(1): 23-32.
  84. Yılmaz M, Ok T. (2012). Geyik Elması (Malus trilobata C.K. Schneid.)’nın Bazı Biyolojik, Ekolojik ve Etnobotanik Özellikleri” Kahramanmaraş Sütçü İmam Üniversitesi Doğa Bilimler Dergisi, Özel Sayı:156-160.
  85. Bulut Y. (2006). Manavgat Yöresinin Faydalı Bitkileri, Yüksek Lisans Tezi, Süleyman Demirel Üniversitesi/ Fen Bilimleri Enstitüsü, Isparta.
  86. Kordali Ş, Çakır A, Akcin TA, Mete E, Akcin A, Aydın, T, Kılıç H. (2009). Antifungal and herbicidal properties of essential oils and n-hexane extracts of Achillea gypsicola Hub-Mor. and Achillea biebersteinii Afan. (Asteraceae). Industrial Crops and Products. 29:562-570
  87. Bayar, Y., & Genc, N. (2021). Total Phenolic, Total Flavonoids, Antioxidant and Antifungal Activity of Inula viscosaExtracts from Turkey.
  88. Akgül, C, Ünver AA, Can N. (2017). “Gölevezin Beslenmede Kullanımı ve Sağlık Üzerine Etkisi”. Aydın Gastronomy. 1(2):51-56.
  89. Akgün B, Alma, MH, Ertaş M, Fidan MS. (2004). Kahramanmaraş yöresinde kullanılan geleneksel bitki türleri ve kullanım yerleri. Geleneksel Gıdalar Sempozyumu. Van:305-310.
  90. Kılıç N. (2010). Türk mutfağının Ege-Akdeniz karakterinin kültürel ve turistik açıdan incelenmesi: Ayvalık örneği. Uzmanlık tezi, T.C. Kültür ve Turizm Bakanlığı Güzel Sanatlar Genel Müdürlüğü, Ankara.
  91. Ceylan, I., & Oktay, H. (1995). A study on the pharyngeal size in different skeletal patterns. American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics, 108(1), 69-75.
  92. Binici, A. (2002). Baharat değerlendirme raporu. Orta Anadolu İhracatçı Birlikleri Genel Sekreterliği, 1, 37.
  93. Özhatay, N., Koyuncu, M., Atay, S., & Byfield, A. (1997). Türkiye'nin doğal tıbbi bitkilerinin ticareti hakkında bir çalışma. Doğal Hayatı Koruma Derneği.
  94. Bayram, E., Kırıcı, S., Tansı, S., Yılmaz, G., Kızıl, O. A. S., & Telci, İ. (2010). Tibbi ve aromatik bitkiler üretiminin arttirilmasi olanaklari. TMMOB Ziraat Mühendisleri Odasi, Ziraat Mühendisligi VII. Teknik Kongresi, 11, 15.

 

Suggested For You
Creative Commons License

Open Access by Magnus Med Club Ltd is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. Based On a Work at magnusmedclub.com

©2018 Magnus Med Club Ltd. All rights Reserved. Traditional Medicine is an Independent Peer-Reviewed Traditional Medicine Journal. Terms of ServicePrivacy Policy